Choosing where to stay at Walt Disney World is one of the most exciting—and sometimes challenging—parts of planning your Disney vacation. During our most recent trip, we had the unique opportunity to experience two very different Disney resorts: Disney’s Coronado Springs Resort and Disney’s Polynesian Village Resort. Both offer incredible amenities and immersive theming, but they cater to different needs and preferences.
Here’s our detailed comparison of these two standout resorts, looking at key categories like rooms, transportation, pools, and dining to help you decide which might be the best fit for your family.
Coronado Springs Resort Overview
Disney’s Coronado Springs Resort is a moderate resort with a stunning blend of Southwest-inspired architecture and modern luxury. The resort is divided into the casitas, ranchos, and cabanas sections, as well as the impressive Gran Destino Tower, which adds a touch of sophistication. Its central location within Walt Disney World makes it a convenient choice for families visiting all four parks.
- Pools: The Dig Site feature pool with a Mayan-themed waterslide and three leisure pools spread throughout the property.
- Dining: Multiple options, including the casual El Mercado del Coronado food court, the relaxing Three Bridges Bar and Grill, and the signature dining experience at Toledo – Tapas, Steak & Seafood in Gran Destino Tower.
- Bars and Lounges: Barcelona Lounge, Dahlia Lounge, and Siesta Pool Bar provide fantastic options for a refreshing drink.
Polynesian Village Resort Overview
Disney’s Polynesian Village Resort is a deluxe resort that immerses you in a tropical paradise inspired by the South Pacific. With lush vegetation, tiki torches, and stunning views of Magic Kingdom, this resort offers a tranquil yet luxurious Disney experience.
Key features include:
- Pools: The Lava Pool, with a volcano and waterslide, and the quieter Oasis Pool.
- Dining: Renowned restaurants like ‘Ohana and Kona Café, quick-service options like Captain Cook’s, and the whimsical Trader Sam’s Grog Grotto. Plus, you can enjoy a delicious Dole Whip from Pineapple Lanai.
- Transportation: Monorail access to Magic Kingdom and EPCOT, plus boat transportation and buses to the other parks.
Comparing Rooms: Comfort and Space
Both resorts have undergone renovations in recent years, offering modern and stylish rooms with plenty of storage and USB charging ports. While the rooms at Coronado Springs are sleek and functional, the newly reimagined Moana-themed rooms at Polynesian add an extra dose of Disney magic.
The Polynesian rooms have a notable advantage for families, offering a pull-out couch that provides an additional sleeping space. This was a game-changer for our kids, giving them separate areas to rest and recharge.
Winner: Polynesian Resort
The pull-out couch and vibrant theming give the Polynesian a slight edge in this category.
Transportation: Convenience Matters
When it comes to getting around Walt Disney World, transportation options can make or break your experience.
- Coronado Springs: Offers bus service to all four parks and Disney Springs. With four bus stops around the resort, it’s easy to hop on and head out for the day.
- Polynesian: Provides monorail access to Magic Kingdom and EPCOT (via the Ticket and Transportation Center), a walking path to Magic Kingdom, and bus service to the other parks.
While the monorail is a fantastic perk for Magic Kingdom fans, we found that Coronado Springs’ central location made travel times to all four parks feel more balanced.
Winner: Coronado Springs Resort
For families planning to visit all four parks, the convenience and central location of Coronado Springs win out.
Pools: A Place to Relax and Play
Both resorts offer unique and exciting pool experiences, but their designs cater to slightly different needs.
- Coronado Springs: The Dig Site features a large pool with a Mayan pyramid centerpiece and a 123-foot waterslide, perfect for older kids who love to swim and play. The spacious layout also makes it easy to find a quiet spot to relax.
- Polynesian: The Lava Pool is iconic, with its volcano theme and a view of Cinderella Castle. However, it’s smaller and can feel crowded. The Oasis Pool offers a quieter alternative.
Our kids preferred the larger and deeper pool at Coronado Springs, which gave them more room to splash and play.
Winner: Coronado Springs Resort
The expansive Dig Site pool and quieter atmosphere make it the clear favorite for families.
Dining: Quick-Service vs. Sit-Down Options
Both resorts offer excellent dining options, but the style and variety differ.
- Coronado Springs: Features a range of options, from quick-service meals at El Mercado del Coronado to upscale dining at Toledo. Three Bridges Bar and Grill was a standout for its relaxed atmosphere and delicious food. We also appreciated the variety of snacks and drinks available throughout the resort.
- Polynesian: Offers fan-favorite dining experiences like ‘Ohana and Kona Café, as well as the fun and immersive Trader Sam’s. However, the quick-service options felt limited compared to Coronado Springs.
For families who enjoy quick and casual meals, Coronado Springs takes the lead. However, if you’re looking for iconic Disney dining experiences, the Polynesian is hard to beat.
Winner: Tie
The best choice depends on your dining preferences—casual and varied vs. iconic sit-down experiences.
Final Verdict: Which Resort is Right for You?
Both Disney’s Coronado Springs Resort and Disney’s Polynesian Village Resort offer incredible stays with unique perks. However, the right choice depends on your family’s priorities:
- Choose Coronado Springs if you’re looking for a budget-friendly yet luxurious stay with a central location, larger pools, and a variety of quick-service dining options.
- Choose Polynesian if you want deluxe amenities, tropical theming, and easy access to Magic Kingdom and EPCOT.
For our family, Coronado Springs edged out Polynesian due to its spacious pool, balanced transportation, and versatile dining options. But no matter which resort you choose, you’re guaranteed a magical stay at Walt Disney World.
What’s your favorite Disney resort? Let us know in the comments below!
