Marvel fans have been left disheartened following the confirmation of the cancellation of the fan-favorite TV show Agatha All Along. This news adds to an ongoing debate about the uneven reception of Marvel’s Disney+ series.
Marvel’s venture into streaming has seen both triumphs and struggles. Early Disney+ successes like WandaVision, Loki, and Hawkeye highlighted the studio’s ability to craft unique stories that expanded the Marvel Cinematic Universe. However, more recent efforts such as Secret Invasion and Echo have failed to resonate with the same level of enthusiasm, even among loyal MCU fans.
Agatha All Along Axed After Season 1
Agatha All Along, which starred Kathryn Hahn as the mischievous Agatha Harkness from WandaVision, was a bright spot among recent offerings. The show, centered on Agatha’s quest to regain her powers, received an 84% critical score and an 83% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes, reflecting strong approval from both critics and viewers.
Despite its success, fans hoping for a second season were left disappointed when Patti LuPone, who portrayed Lilia Calderu in the series, revealed that the show will not continue.
Speaking on Andy Cohen Live, LuPone explained that showrunner Jac Schaeffer prefers to focus on standalone projects. “[Schaeffer] said, ‘I don’t do second seasons,’” LuPone shared. “She said, ‘They wanted me to do a second season of WandaVision and I didn’t. There’s too much to write.’”
The news sparked a wave of frustration online. One fan took to X, formerly known as Twitter, to express disbelief: “WAIT WHAT??? You can’t just make one of the best Marvel products and then dip on us like that??? The show had the lowest budget of any MCU Disney series and ended up being one of the best stories. We need more Agatha and Wiccan and the search for Tommy!!”
Another fan criticized Disney’s streaming strategy, stating, “This is why I’ve stopped watching Disney… You can’t get a season two for series you like…. And if you do get another season, it’s two years before it comes on… How in the world do you operate a streaming channel like this?”
Marvel Limits TV Shows
While Agatha All Along joins a growing list of Marvel shows with just one season, this approach is not unusual for the studio. Apart from Loki and What If?, most Marvel series have been designed as limited runs. The upcoming Your Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man and Daredevil: Born Again are among the few exceptions, with confirmed multi-season plans.
This decision comes during a challenging period for Marvel, as the studio faces criticism for an overabundance of content that some say has diluted its appeal. Combined with a string of lackluster box office performances and Disney+ misfires, fans worry the franchise may have prioritized quantity over quality.
Last year was a notably barren year for Marvel Studios release-wise, with just the one outing on the big screen – Deadpool & Wolverine (2024) – and three debuts on Disney+: the third (and final) season of What If?, Echo, and Agatha All Along.
For now, fans of Agatha All Along will have to be content with the single season, as Marvel seemingly continues its trend of focusing on self-contained stories. Whether this strategy will reinvigorate its standing remains to be seen.
Do you think Marvel should continue Agatha All Along?
