Walt Disney World Resort is a foodie paradise with nearly 400 dining locations, offering everything from quick bites to luxurious sit-down meals. Dining at Disney is an experience all its own, and no Disney vacation feels complete without indulging in the parks’ culinary magic.
While Disney Springs and EPCOT are often lauded as the ultimate foodie destinations at Walt Disney World, the Magic Kingdom’s dining scene tends to spark debates among fans.
Why Magic Kingdom’s Dining Gets Mixed Reviews
Disney Springs boasts over 70 dining spots, many helmed by celebrity chefs, offering dishes crafted by renowned culinary minds like José Andrés and Maneet Chauhan. EPCOT, with its World Showcase and newly expanded neighborhoods (World Celebration, World Discovery, and World Nature), serves as the go-to theme park for international cuisines and unique flavors.
However, when it comes to Magic Kingdom, opinions are divided. While it’s home to iconic treats like DOLE Whip, Cheeseburger Spring Rolls, and the Nutella and Fruit Waffle, the park’s sit-down restaurants often fall short of the praise heaped on its counterparts. Among these, Liberty Tree Tavern and Tony’s Town Square Restaurant spark particular debate.
Liberty Tree Tavern: A Feast of Comfort Food
Located in Liberty Square, Liberty Tree Tavern offers an all-you-care-to-enjoy Thanksgiving feast, featuring dishes like roast turkey, house-made mac and cheese, mashed potatoes, cornbread stuffing, and their famous toffee cake. With its colonial charm, Liberty Tree Tavern is a favorite for families looking for a hearty meal in a cozy atmosphere.
What Guests Are Saying:
Some fans hail Liberty Tree as a top dining option at the Magic Kingdom, praising its generous portions and nostalgic flavors. Others, however, feel the pricing doesn’t match the quality, noting that the offerings can feel a bit heavy for a day in the parks.
“Liberty Tree is a top-notch dinner, but it’s pricey for what you get. My last meal there was underwhelming, especially the pot roast.”
Tony’s Town Square: Classic Italian on Main Street, U.S.A.
Step onto Main Street, U.S.A., and you’ll find Tony’s Town Square, a charming eatery inspired by Disney’s animated classic, Lady and the Tramp. With a menu featuring spaghetti and meatballs, chicken parmigiana, shrimp scampi, and gelato, it offers a taste of Italy in a family-friendly setting.
What Guests Are Saying:
Tony’s has had its share of criticism over the years, earning a reputation as one of the weaker dining spots in the park. However, recent updates to the menu and improved food quality have won over some skeptics.
“I’ve dined at Tony’s a few times and loved it! The food has improved, and it’s a great spot if you’re craving Italian.”
Still, others argue that neither Liberty Tree nor Tony’s delivers the kind of dining experience they expect at Walt Disney World.
“If I have the choice, I’ll leave the Magic Kingdom and head to EPCOT. The dining options there are unbeatable!”
Alternatives Within Magic Kingdom
For those who aren’t drawn to either Liberty Tree or Tony’s, there are other notable dining options in the Magic Kingdom worth considering:
- Jungle Navigation Co. Ltd. Skipper Canteen: Located in Adventureland, this table-service spot offers bold flavors inspired by cuisines from Asia, South America, and Africa. Dishes like Sustainable Fish Fillet and “Tastes Like Chicken” Because It Is are fan favorites.
- Columbia Harbour House: A quick-service location in Liberty Square, known for its New England-inspired seafood offerings like Lobster Rolls and Clam Chowder.
- Cinderella’s Royal Table: For a more magical experience, this iconic dining location inside Cinderella Castle offers character interactions and a regal menu.
Should You Stay in Magic Kingdom or Head Elsewhere?
Many fans argue that if dining is your priority, EPCOT or Disney Springs may be the better choice. EPCOT’s World Showcase offers an international array of dining experiences, from authentic Japanese cuisine at Teppan Edo to classic French dishes at Chefs de France. Disney Springs, on the other hand, is a mecca for food lovers, featuring diverse options like Chef Art Smith’s Homecomin’, Wine Bar George, and The Edison.
Still, dining at the Magic Kingdom has its unique charm. Whether you’re savoring an indulgent meal at Liberty Tree, enjoying a taste of Italy at Tony’s, or exploring other dining options within the park, there’s something special about sharing a meal surrounded by the magic of Disney.
Tips for Dining Success at Magic Kingdom
- Plan Ahead: Advanced dining reservations are highly recommended for table-service restaurants. You can make these reservations up to 60 days in advance through the My Disney Experience app.
- Follow Your Taste Buds: Choose a restaurant that matches your mood and cravings. Whether it’s Thanksgiving-style comfort food or Italian classics, pick what appeals to you.
- Consider Timing: For a quieter meal, book an early lunch or late dinner.
- Try Snacks: Don’t overlook Magic Kingdom’s iconic treats like the DOLE Whip, Nutella and Fruit Waffle, or a Mickey-shaped pretzel.
Final Thoughts
While Magic Kingdom’s dining options may not rival those of EPCOT or Disney Springs, they still hold their own Disney magic. Whether you opt for the colonial charm of Liberty Tree Tavern, the nostalgic atmosphere of Tony’s Town Square, or one of the park’s other hidden gems, there’s a dining experience waiting to add to your magical day.
Where do you love to dine in the Magic Kingdom? Share your favorite spots in the comments below!
Why to people make things so complicated? Liberty Tree provided us with the most important things a meal should have, good food, good company and good pricing for Disney. Just enjoy it. I do when I am in the Magic Kingdom.