Disney Recast ‘Phineas and Ferb’ Character, but Reason Remains a Mystery
Nearly two decades after it first captured audiences with its quirky humor and catchy tunes, Phineas and Ferb returned to screens in 2025 — but not without stirring some controversy.
The reboot’s arrival on Disney+ had fans eager for nostalgia but also noticing that some familiar faces have changed. What’s behind these new voices, and what does this mean for longtime viewers?
The original series debuted in 2007, quickly becoming a cultural phenomenon for its inventive storytelling and memorable characters. Now, with a string of new episodes already under its belt – and more on the way – longtime fans have been reacquainting themselves with the inventive stepbrothers.
While the recasting of Ferb from Thomas Sangster to David Errigo Jr. was known ahead of time, another change caught many by surprise.
New Voice, New Era for Jeremy Johnson
Jeremy Johnson, the charming object of Candace Flynn’s affection, has a fresh voice in this revival.
Mitchel Musso, who originally voiced Jeremy and is also well known from Disney Channel’s Hannah Montana, no longer lends his voice to the character. This change was unexpected for many viewers, especially since Musso had reprised the role as recently as the 2020 movie Phineas and Ferb the Movie: Candace Against the Universe.
Musso’s departure has not been officially explained by Disney, but his history offers some context. The actor’s DUI arrest in 2011 led to his character being removed from Pair of Kings and the cancellation of PrankStars. At the time, Musso acknowledged the incident, saying, “In becoming an adult, I have learned firsthand that stepping up and taking responsibility is the best way to move forward.”
They replace Jeremy’s voice in season 5 of phineas and ferb….. he was previously voiced by Mitchell Musso #PhineasandFerbSeason5 #PhineasAndFerb
Despite this setback, Musso continued working with Disney on projects connected to the Phineas and Ferb universe, including Milo Murphy’s Law and previous Phineas and Ferb movies. But a second arrest in August 2023, involving public intoxication and theft charges that were later dismissed, may have influenced the decision to recast his role.
The incident stemmed from allegations that Musso had been intoxicated and belligerent at a Texas hotel following an alleged theft. Musso disputed the claims, and the charges were later dismissed.
What This Means for the Show
Mitchel Musso’s departure from the show marks a significant shift in Phineas and Ferb’s voice cast, particularly for fans who grew up associating his voice with Jeremy. The character plays a key role as Candace’s crush and often the distraction that prevents her from “busting” her brothers’ latest inventions.

For a show so deeply rooted in its original voice actors and musical style, any change invites scrutiny. But the reboot manages to balance both nostalgia and a dose of fresh energy. Dan Povenmire, the co-creator, has described this revival as a continuation rather than a reset, giving longtime fans a reason to return while inviting new audiences to discover the inventive world of Phineas, Ferb, and their friends.
The revival’s fifth season wrapped up in January 2026, with the show returning for a sixth season Halloween special in October. With more episodes on the horizon, fans will have further opportunities to revisit the world of Phineas and Ferb – even if some familiar characters sound a little different.
Have you had a chance to watch the new Phineas and Ferb episodes?




